Commenting.


COMMENTING
Due to the move of the blog to Wordpress posts from Jan 2012 onward will have commenting disabled (when I remember to do it)
Cheers - AE

Friday, 4 February 2011

New Labour, Cobbleition Tories, very few meaningful differences.

I've said this already often enough but Douglas Carswell spells it out loud and clear today.
... From where I'm sitting, the problem is not that the Coalition is failing to be traditionally Tory. Rather it is that ministers are not being radical enough. Yes, the talk is bold, but how much has public policy really altered since May?

Cutting the deficit? Ministers say so, but not the maths. Borrowing is up. Like pretty much every other post-war government, this one seems to be using higher taxes and inflation to solve its debt problems, rather than seriously curb state largesse.

Political reform? All those interesting ideas, mooted at the height of the expense scandal, including recall and open primaries, seem forgotten. Instead we’re to have a referendum on AV – which was in neither Coalition party’s manifesto.

Bonfire of the quangos? It’s gone out.

Localism? Maybe. But what about the localising the money?

Great Repeal Bill? Try googling it.

Europe? This afternoon the government will announce we’re opting into yet another EU proposal on criminal justice. Plus ca change.

Welfare reform? Full marks. But is this a change of policy or an acceleration of the reforms Labour’s James Purnell piloted.

Defence? We carry on cutting what we need, while spending on ruinous contracts we can ill-afford.

New politics? Same sofa.
Quite, and since Douglas Carswell is a Conservative MP and presumably better able than most to see what's going on in his party it's a fairly safe bet the rest of us who thought the new government was depressingly similar to the old one didn't imagine it. But it does raise one intriguing question.

Why the hell is Douglas Carswell still a Conservative when the party isn't?

Comments (2)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Organised and manufactured opposition. Don't trust Carswell or any other so called dissenter. Google Cass Sunstien (he of the "nudge" principle). They are selling an illusion and playing with your mind. By feeding false hope they are effectively preventing the people taking direct action and preserving the corrupt political system. IE it will be different next time, wait and vote for somebody else in 5 years time. Trust me I am a Politicians, we are going to change, its in our manifesto, guaranteed referendum, we will listen, your cheque is in the post and I promise not to cum in your mouth.

Wankers, the lot of them.
1 reply · active 738 weeks ago
Not sure I'd accuse Carswell of feeding false hopes given that he says a lot of what other people say, give us the promised referendum or failing that and in/out of EU referendum instead being top of the list. False hope? No, I don't think so. It's not in his power to give that or any of the other things he says would be a good idea and which appeal to others. Cameron, now... well he certainly could and he once promised to, as did Nick Clegg. I'd call 'em both guilty as charged. Nor is it a trust thing with Carswell since I know I disagree with him on a number of things and as above, his ability to betray me is limited by his position as a backbencher on the margins of his party and with zero prospect of a government position. But I do wonder what on earth he's still doing in the Tory party. Perhaps he feels that his seat will, like many Labour seats, elect anything that rolls up with a blue rosette nailed to it, and that where he is at least gives him and those who hold similar opinions a voice in Westminster while maintaining independence from Cameramong's mob. Perhaps he hopes the Tories will come back to where he is, but if so then I think he'll be disappointed.

Post a new comment

Comments by

Related Posts with Thumbnails