Commenting.


COMMENTING
Due to the move of the blog to Wordpress posts from Jan 2012 onward will have commenting disabled (when I remember to do it)
Cheers - AE

Tuesday, 24 May 2011

Apocalypse reset

Click for linky

Everybody panic, the end of the world is back on again.
Mr Camping, who predicted that 200 million Christians would be taken to heaven on Saturday before the earth was destroyed, said he felt so terrible when his doomsday prediction did not come true that he left home and took refuge in a motel with his wife.
His independent ministry, Family Radio International, spent millions - some of it from donations made by followers - on more than 5000 billboards and 20 RVs plastered with the Judgment Day message.
But Mr Camping said that he had now realised the apocalypse would come five months after May 21, the original date he predicted. He had earlier said October 21 was when the globe would be consumed by a fireball.
No real surprise there since these doomsday types do have a bit of a mental block when it comes to events they've predicted with absolute certainty not actually happening. Far from being forced to concede that (a) they were mistaken and (b) now look like complete tits it's apparently not unusual for their belief to actually get stronger as a result of failed predictions.
Shouldn't the failure of a very precise prediction for which they had made extreme sacrifices have prompted disillusionment and disgust — not greater commitment?
Not according to Festinger's theory of cognitive dissonance, which predicts that the more we have given and invested in a particular point of view, the less likely we will be to abandon it in the face of contrary evidence. It's the same cognitive process that kicks in when we are made to behave in ways that are inconsistent with our beliefs; in the face of that disharmony, we often change our beliefs to be congruent with our behaviors and self-perception.
That cognitive dissonance thing again, and as the article points out it's not new to doomsayers in general or Camping in particular. They get so emotionally, mentally and financially invested in their prophecies of disaster that letting go of them when they don't happen becomes very difficult. Easier to reset your belief a little and say you mistaken about the date than reboot your head completely and admit the whole idea was wrong from the start. This is Rapture v2.1.

So come October 22nd when we're all still here we can go back to worrying about the end of the world from warble gloaming instead, which is entirely different in that when predictions don't match the reality you have to change your model rather than abandon the overall theory. This is of course not at all the same as a religious nut saying he made an error on the detail but that the end is definitely nigh anyway. No, not even a little bit like it. Because these warnings come from the government, clearly impartial while still attempting to persuade us of the need for the carbon tax PM Gingery Dullard specifically ruled out before the election but which is now demanded by the Green tail waging the minority Labor government dog, and from the equally impartial Climate Commission, established by the aforementioned Gingery Dullard and headed by Tim Flannery. Not the remotest chance that their apocalypse is either overstated or will not materialise on schedule, or that they are as deeply invested in their conviction of the doom that we have wrought upon ourselves, meted out by an angry God Gaia, as Harold Camping is in his belief in his apocalypse, is there?

Dooooomed, but available to stand in for any catastrophists

Comments (8)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Yep, and anyone with a vested interest in the status quo. And Big Eco have such an interest. I'd say they're also political twats.
In the past such "prophets" have got away with getting it wrong as they never had worldwide publicity, nor did they spend tons of money on publicity. In some way he was the victim of his own success. This is not saying he is a victim like the one who spent $146K. But he brought it on himself by courting publicity that when it goes wrong he has a lot of explaining to do. We'll see if he gets the same level of publicity in Oct. If I were him, I would stop the publicity just in case he was wrong again! Maybe this might do the whole religion thing a bit of good - in other words cut them down in size.
My recent post Picture Caption Contest
1 reply · active 722 weeks ago
Yeah, for every Nostradamus or Mother Shipton there was probably thousands more history never noticed. These days the web and broadcast media make it easier for the crazies both to make a living from the gullible and entertain the rest of us.

That said your mention of the guy who spent $146K on advertising, and I think now hasn't got a pot to piss in, has reminded me of a collection that was apparently going on in Seattle or somewhere round there for apocalypse disaster relief for those not Raptured. In the event it didn't happen the money was to go to local charities, and presumably that's what happened. Perhaps before October there might be some similar whip rounds, with the difference that if it doesn't happen again the money collected could help out those poor unfortunate souls who've been persuaded to ruin themselves financially in the expectation of there being no need for money come October 22nd.
microdave's avatar

microdave · 723 weeks ago

Like the weather forecast, if you keep repeating the same information, eventually you will get it correct!

Private Frazer was right....
1 reply · active 722 weeks ago
Yeah, but this is like the weatherman coming on and predicting heavy showers of antique Bakelite radios and golf balls the size of hailstones.
james higham's avatar

james higham · 723 weeks ago

Far from being forced to concede that (a) they were mistaken and (b) now look like complete tits it's apparently not unusual for their belief to actually get stronger as a result of failed predictions.

Not unlike a socialist.
1 reply · active 722 weeks ago
Very much like one.

Post a new comment

Comments by

Related Posts with Thumbnails